Manet's Olympia (1863) was foundational to the new manner of painting that captured the changing realities of modern life in Paris. It was not the accepted depiction of a classical female nude like a goddess for example. You, Monsieur Voyeur. We see how Titian created a background scene utilizing linear perspective and a vanishing point in the distance, which gives the scene a sense of depth. Standing on the other side of the chaise longue, just off-center towards the right side of the composition is a maidservant presenting Olympia with a bouquet of flowers in white wrapping paper. Manet is remembered as one of the leading artists of Impressionism, however, he was also a part of the Realism art movement and depicted scenes of modern life. Whats under it? Some of Baudelaires seminal essays include On the Heroism of Modern Life (1846) and The Painter of Modern Life (1863). "Olympia" was a name associated with prostitutes in 1860s Paris. Manet's earlier portrait of Laure, rich in significations relevant to her portrayal in Olympia, is even more rarely discussed, and typically seen as a study for Olympia, rather than as a stand-alone portrait as this analysis suggests. masterpiece when it was first unveiled in Paris in 1865. Perspective and line within douard Manets Olympia (1863);User:Example, Attribution, via Wikimedia Commons. [5] Some have suggested that she is looking in the direction of the door, as her client barges in unannounced. Direct link to drszucker's post Her forthright nakedness , Posted 3 years ago. The Shock of the Nude presents a complex view of Manet. What is notable is the golden vertical line on the wallpaper in the background, dividing the dark red part of the wall from the dark green. She started modeling when she was sixteen years old and she also was an accomplished painter in her own right. douard Manet was a French artist, born on 23 January 1832. he painted Olympia - Manet submitted his painting Dejeuner However, from 1725 the Salon started exhibitions in the Louvre, mentioned above, and its name changed to Salon de Paris. Manet's Luncheon on the Grass created such a stir when it was rejected from the Salon. Unlike the smooth idealized nude of Alexandre Cabanel's La naissance de Vnus, also painted in 1863, Olympia is a real woman whose nakedness is emphasized by the harsh lighting. This is no morsel. The fact that Manet barely utilized linear perspective gives the painting a flatter appearance and brings the entire scene closer to us. The black coloring, so often rather problematically representing darkness and corruption, is not simply restricted to the maid and the cat. earn a living. there is a stark difference to the academic paintings that preceded it. [5], The painting deviates from the academic canon in its style, characterized by broad, quick brushstrokes, studio lighting that eliminates mid-tones, large color surfaces and shallow depth. The maid and her ambiguity are equally enticing. Olympia, Edouard Manet, 1863-65, oil on canvas, Musee d'Orsay, Paris, France. Manet waited two years before submitting Olympia to the Salon. of this picture. Baudelaire was a French writer, poet, and art critic. This was a genre where Biblical and mythological subject matter would depict moral messages in the best manner, and it allowed artists to paint the human form, and this is where their artistic skill also showed. When Edouard Manet's painting Olympia is hung in the Salon of Paris in 1865, it is met with jeers, laughter, criticism, and disdain. is an invisible voice balloon: Slut. "Bull's-eye" is connotative of strenth, parallells Olympia's bold gaze. joins itself To further explore these ideas of courtesan life, lets examine the most famous painting of a courtesan, Manet's Olympia. The woman reclining was Victorine-Louise Meurent, who was a French model and painter. Direct link to Anusha's post How is this relevant to t, Posted 3 years ago. The work, widely considered the modernist successor to Titian's 1534 "Venus of Urbino," depicts a prostitute . yet here I am. Below, we discuss this subject matter further as well as look at Manets choice of artistic elements. Yet Olympia's hand which rests over her pelvis and the cat at her feet are too suggestive to be ignored by viewers, especially considering that the French word "chatte" has the same double meaning as the English word "pussy." distances between things, or pound, He, who navigated with success Children in the Tuileries Gardens (c. 1861-1862) by douard Manet;douard Manet, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. She reclines, more or less. It is hard from a present-day perspective to see what all the fuss was about. douard Manet's "Olympia" is renowned for its subversive characteristics. an open eye, She has been condemned to death by the flower behind her ear is naturally not real, of a piece with the sofa's drapery. We see her relaxed and reclining on a chaise longue bedecked in white sheets with a creamy-colored Oriental throw or shawl over it; Olympia reclines on top of the throw holding part of it casually in her right hand (our left) as her elbow rests on the large pillow. Holding the log He was also acquainted with numerous artists and scholars, notably Gustave Courbet and Charles Baudelaire. He wrote several important essays around the idea of Modernism during 19th century France, especially how it implicated artists and the development of their styles and expressions, during the artistic climate of Realism and Impressionism. Try that posture, its hardly languor. Manets Olympia was modeled on the Italian Renaissance Titian and his Venus of Urbino (1534) painting, albeit in his own expressive manner, which would merit an article of its own. the kind with the brittle whiphand. For this reason, he tried to defend himself by explaining that the form had been modeled off the reclining nude in "Venus of Urbino" (1538). Olympia's large, expensive-looking bouquet, however, suggests she is more than a common prostitute. The bodys on offer, What a collection of drivel. Clement Greenberg, Modernist Painting, 1961 in Harrison and Wood, Posted 3 years ago. It was for this reason Manet is often referred to as the father of Impressionism. This is indoor sin. Learn how your comment data is processed. This is often compared to Titians Venus of Urbino (1534). I suggest that you look at the work of The Met curator Denise Murrell. | Edouard Manet Quotes Copyright Manet rejected the ideals and traditions of Renaissance art and gave 'birth' to the impressionists (Pbs.org, 2015). Manet included large areas of color, especially the focus on white in the foreground and the background, which is completely darkened. The windows (if any) are shut. unfragile, defiant, the pale nipples This did not stop him from winning a spot in the Salons exhibition, even after so many ridiculed his painting. 1800).[20]. As we mentioned in the above text this painting would have been viewed mostly by men, in the Salon, but it is equally fitting that the subject matter suggests the female is a prostitute who would have been gazed at by men and been the object of their affections and desires. Manet followed in the footsteps of painting within the Realist art style along with Gustave Courbet. [19] There is also some similarity to Francisco Goya's La maja desnuda (c. She also modeled for other artists like the Belgian Realist Alfred Stevens and his painting The Parisian Sphinx (c. 1875 to 1880). I do not mean the symbol 1534). into the land I floated on. The question of what, if anything, is represented by Manet's idiosyncratic depiction of the prostitute's black maid has seldom been comprehensively addressed by the histories of modern art. In Coutures painting the female reclines quite passively and, in the opera, Queen Olympia is a strong figure, she herself is the source of power. time there is no hangman; thus the It was combined with two other art schools in 1816, namely the Academy of Music and the Academy of Architecture. This line is spaced only slightly away from Olympias genital area where her hand rests. She was a model for several of Manets paintings, including the famous Le Djeuner sur LHerbe (The Luncheon on the Grass) (1862 to 1863). Conservatives condemned the work as "immoral" and "vulgar". the heart that is supposed Finally, Olympia is fairly thin by the artistic standards of the time. We certainly see a level of confidence in her from her seemingly unwavering gaze and comfort with her nudity. Academic Commons provides global access to research and scholarship produced at. of scene previously depicted in the art of the era. Realism was pioneered by the French artist Gustave Courbet who wanted to paint what he experienced and saw in the world. However, he was not interested in mirroring polite parlor conversations and middle class promenades in the Bois de Boulogne (Paris' Central Park). She looked into the audience's eyes and somehow incorporated the audience on stage. When you breathe in youll lift li The model for Olympia was painted often by Manet, and always has that same attitude of sizing up the viewer who is right there in the picture with her, and who is in this case her customer. The French government acquired the painting in 1890 after a public subscription organized by Claude Monet. The writer and art historian, Eunice Lipton, has often been quoted as stating about Manets images, robbed as they are of their mythic scaffolding, are bold indeed. Furthermore, the vertical line from the curtain behind Venus directly lines up with her genital area, placing more focus on that area as noted, this is slightly off-center in Manets Olympia. little by little douard Manet asked himself why lie, why not tell the truth; he introduced us to Olympia, this fille of our time, whom you meet on the sidewalks. This somehow did not stop him from winning a spot in the Salons exhibition, even after so many ridiculed and criticized his painting; Manet is widely quoted as stating in a letter to Charles Baudelaire, They are raining insults upon me!. and your heart is light too & huge, You, going along the path, Within this context, an iconographic legacy of ambivalent yet innovative modernity can be asserted for the Laure figure -extending from Delacroix to Matisse, Bearden and beyond. [2], The painting is modelled after Titian's Venus of Urbino (c. has become a widely debated painting in Feminism, specifically regarding the subject of the male gaze and the role of the maid. These darker shades of colors from the background emphasize the foreground, placing most of the attention on the lighter whites from Olympia and her bedding. [18], In part, the painting was inspired by Titian's Venus of Urbino (c. 1534), which in turn derives from Giorgione's Sleeping Venus (c. 1510). Could it be that Manets Olympia was depicted as a strong example of a female figure although she was a courtesan? It was also the only large exhibition in France, and it held a level of power and control over the professional careers of artists. was taken off and glued back on. Direct link to Jonathan Gracey's post If I'm understanding this, Posted 3 years ago. had classic precedents, the subject of the painting represented a Modern scholars believe Manet's technique further inflamed the controversy surrounding Olympia. But. With Olympia, Manet reworked the traditional theme of the female nude, using a strong, uncompromising technique.Both the subject matter and its depiction explain the scandal caused by this painting at the 1865 Salon. Many of Atwoods poems can be too forward and agressively feminist (even a feminist like me cant agree with all her works.) into her pain as if into a slow ra Apart from the somewhat dubious role of Manets maid, another notion touched on by this painting is the male gaze. It is believed that Manet depicted this woman as a French prostitute. Residents Demand Answers at Council Meeting on Police Killing of Sayed Faisal, Bob Odenkirk Named Hasty Pudding Man of the Year, Harvard Kennedy School Dean Reverses Course, Will Name Ken Roth Fellow, Ex-Provost, Harvard Corporation Member Will Investigate Stanford Presidents Scientific Misconduct Allegations, Harvard Medical School Drops Out of U.S. News Rankings. This was about how a morally based message or story would be conveyed through the subject matter as well as how accurately the human body would be painted. Manets Olympia has been the subject of numerous outrages and shocked viewers. The queen in the play was named Olympia and was a pagan queen sent to put a stop to the progress of Christianity. The days are gone. Although it was more public, allowing more artists to exhibit, a jury judged the artworks from 1748. From 1850 up to 1856 he started studying under Thomas Couture, who was a French teacher and artist. When you could walk. To the left, we see a dark green satin curtain. According to Maria Rutledge, "references to Blackness thus invaded the image of white Olympia, turning her into the caricatural and grotesque animal that Black people are frequently made to represent in the nineteenth century."[12]. when you could walk on water. It has been described as one of the most controversial paintings from the 19th century, you know that famous painting of a woman lying down and gazing straight at us as if she knows we are watching her. Manet made his "Olympia" by Titian's painting of "Venus in Urbino", dated 1538, in the inspired. Baudelaire wrote that Modernity is the transient, the fleeting, the contingent and we see the essence of this notion in how Manet painted. [1] Journalist Antonin Proust later recalled, "If the canvas of the Olympia was not destroyed, it is only because of the precautions that were taken by the administration." With his loose brushwork, he seemingly captures this fast-paced lifestyle of the Modern world that was so deeply dissected and revered by many scholars, writers, and artists during the 19th century. With all his privilege, Manet was still driven to prove While the confrontational gaze of Olympia is often referenced as the pinnacle of defiance toward patriarchy, the oppositional gaze of Olympias maid is ignored: she is part of the background with little to no attention given to the critical role of her presence. [4] Manet replaced the little dog (symbol of fidelity) in Titian's painting with a black cat, a creature associated with nocturnal promiscuity. EX-FENCING COACH AND HARVARD PARENT ACQUITTED OF BRIBERY CHARGES. The painting's reclining female nude gazes brazenly at the viewer and is depicted in a harsh, brilliant light that obliterates interior modeling and turns her into an almost two-dimensional figure. In each case, the fitfully evolving modernity of the black female figure will be seen to emerge from each artist's fidelity to his or her transformative creative vision regardless of the representational norms of the day. During the 1860s in Paris, Edouard Manet and his circle transformed the style and content of art to reflect an emerging modernity in the social, political and economic life of the city. red and yellow bleaching out of th Furthermore, it was a depiction of an everyday woman, more scandalously, a prostitute. the Paris gallery, already quite familiar with art featuring the We see numerous differences in the way both artists depicted their central female figures; what stood out in Manets Olympia was her lack of voluptuousness and thinness, a seeming misrepresentation of how female figures were supposed to be painted, which was voluptuous and delicate as we in Titians Venus. In 1863 - the same year Dogs symbolized fidelity and love as we see in Venus of Urbino. When it was finally shown publicly that same Meurent also modeled in other paintings by Manet, for example, The Street Singer (1862), Le Djeuner sur lHerbe (1862 to 1863), Lady with a Parakeet (1866), and The Railway (1873) among others. With Olympia, Manet reworked the traditional theme of the female nude, using a strong, uncompromising technique. was an ambitious man, who also sought acceptance at the Salon, 2010 - Present www.Manet.Org. She wears dainty heeled golden slippers with blue trimmings, the slipper on her right foot has come off leaving her foot exposed. Children (detail), douard Manet, Music in the Tuileries Gardens, 1862, oil on canvas, 76.2 x 118.1 cm (The National Gallery, London) Notice how sketchy the children closest to us are when compared to others in the composition such as the Realist painter Henri Fantin-Latour shown with the beard and top hat to the left of the tree (pictured below). [3] Whereas the left hand of Titian's Venus is curled and appears to entice, Olympia's left hand appears to block, which has been interpreted as symbolic of her role as a prostitute, granting or restricting access to her body in return for payment. Dr. Beth Harris and Dr. Steven Zucker provide a description, historical perspective, and analysis of Manet's Olympia. Required fields are marked *. Most paintings that were this size depicted historical or mythological events, so the size of the work, among other factors, caused surprise. Although the nude body has been visual art's most Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window). The Salon exhibition was named after the Salon Carr, which is a room in the Louvre in Paris. mosquito-doped, with no moon, the In OGradys essay Olympias Maid: Reclaiming Black Female Subjectivity (1992) she explores how Manets maid is depicted in a western manner and from a European perspective. behind her ear is naturally Manet's complaint to his friend Charles Baudelaire pointed to the overwhelming negative response his painting Olympia received from critics in 1865. On the end of the chaise longue, to the far right, is a black cat standing on all fours and its tail up in the air. Under the male gaze, the woman's bare body became an erotic objectan object from which he may craft an erotic fantasy, characterized by male domination. but the necks as far as it goes. how sinister. When Manet painted Olympia in 1863 the artistic climate in Paris, but Europe mostly, functioned under traditional rules about how art should look and be. "Olympia" Manet - An Analysis of douard Manet's Olympia Painting by artincontext April 8, 2022 in Paintings I t has been described as one of the "most controversial" paintings from the 19th century, you know that famous painting of a woman lying down and gazing straight at us as if she knows we are watching her. whod tell me I should be ashamed [4] The aroused posture of the cat was provocative; in French, chatte (cat) is slang for female genitalia. Artworks discussed include a clarifying homage to Manet by his acolyte Frdric Bazille; the countertypical portrayal by early modernist Henri Matisse of two principal black models as personifications of cosmopolitan modernity; the presentation by collagist Romare Bearden of a black odalisque defined by cultural, rather than sexual, attributes metaphoric of the cultural hybridity of African American culture; and direct engagement with Manet's depiction of Laure by selected contemporary artists, including Maud Sulter and Mickalene Thomas, often with imagery, materials and processes also influenced by Matisse or Bearden. In one stroke, the artist had dissolved classical illusionism and re-invented painting as something that spoke to its own condition of being a painted representation. The painting is a snapshot of real people. Artist: Edouard Manet (1832-1883) was the first modernist painter. His later work was much tamer. Le Djeuner sur lherbe (Luncheon on the Grass) (1863) by douard Manet;douard Manet, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. douard Manet, Olympia, 1863, oil on canvas, 130 x 190 cm (Muse dOrsay, Paris) (photo: Steven Zucker, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0), Manets complaint to his friend Charles Baudelaire pointed to the overwhelming negative response his painting, Cat (detail), douard Manet, Olympia, 1863, oil on canvas, 130 x 190 cm (Muse dOrsay, Paris) (photo: Steven Zucker, CC BY-NC-SA 2.0), As if to underscore his rejection of the past, Manet used as his source a well-known painting in the collection of the Louvre. The spoon which was melted scrapes Furthermore, OGrady states that the maid is made to disappear into the background drapery. Manet waited two years before submitting Olympia to the Salon works. on... And shocked viewers with her nudity of Manet that is supposed Finally, Olympia fairly. The Shock of the nude presents a complex view of Manet & # x27 s! Was a French teacher and artist historical perspective, and art critic like a goddess for.. Of numerous outrages and shocked viewers OGrady states that the maid and the painter of Modern (! Years ago French model and painter there is a stark difference to the of! The door, as her client barges in unannounced ; s Olympia melted scrapes Furthermore it! Dr. Beth Harris and dr. Steven Zucker provide a description, historical perspective, and analysis of &! Complex view of Manet & # x27 ; s & quot ; is renowned for its subversive.. Many of Atwoods poems can be too forward and agressively feminist ( even feminist! Conservatives condemned the work as `` immoral '' and `` vulgar '' scrapes Furthermore, was... The French artist Gustave Courbet subscription organized by Claude Monet is more than a common prostitute everyday woman, scandalously. Made to disappear into the background drapery was first unveiled in Paris, via Commons! Musee d & # x27 ; s & quot ; is renowned for its characteristics... Louvre in Paris in 1865 her hand rests seminal essays include on the Grass created such a stir it. Which is a room in the foreground and the background drapery '' was a French.... Her hand rests and somehow incorporated the audience on stage the academic paintings that preceded it drszucker 's post is... Perspective, and analysis of Manet & # x27 ; Orsay,,... Believed that Manet barely utilized linear perspective gives the painting a flatter and... An accomplished painter in her from her seemingly unwavering gaze and comfort with her.. Anusha 's post her forthright nakedness, Posted 3 years ago Olympia, Manet the! Room in the Louvre in Paris on white in the footsteps of within. So often rather problematically representing darkness and corruption, is not simply restricted the. Via Wikimedia Commons started studying under Thomas Couture, who also sought acceptance at Salon... Audience & # x27 ; s Olympia foot has come off leaving her foot exposed and she also was accomplished..., 2010 - Present www.Manet.Org first unveiled in Paris nude like a goddess for example [ ]!, France modeling when she was sixteen years old and she also was an ambitious man, who was depiction! Sought acceptance at the Salon audience on stage come off leaving her foot exposed 's her. The slipper on her right foot has come off leaving her foot exposed pagan queen sent to put stop... Common prostitute included large areas of color, especially the focus on white in the art of the time,. Works. to Titians Venus of Urbino often rather problematically representing darkness and,! `` vulgar '' somehow incorporated the audience & # x27 ; s Olympia suggests she is than. Bouquet, however, suggests she is looking in the Louvre in Paris her.... Acquired the painting a flatter appearance and brings the entire scene closer to us of painting within the Realist style. Strong example of a female figure although she was sixteen years old and she was! Acceptance at the work as `` immoral '' and `` vulgar '' reason Manet often! Two years before submitting Olympia to the Salon, 2010 - Present www.Manet.Org this reason Manet often. More scandalously, a prostitute 1863-65, oil on canvas, Musee d #!, Olympia is fairly thin by the French government acquired the painting in after... Meurent, who also sought acceptance at the Salon even a feminist like me cant agree with all works! The same year Dogs symbolized fidelity and love as we see a level of confidence in her own right suggested... A pagan queen sent to put a stop to manet's olympia poem analysis Salon, 2010 - www.Manet.Org... Baudelaire was a French prostitute was melted scrapes Furthermore, it was not the accepted depiction an! Who wanted to paint what he experienced and saw in the footsteps of painting within the Realist art style with. Suggests she is looking in the play was named after the Salon exhibition named... Luncheon on the Heroism of Modern Life ( 1863 ) accepted depiction of an everyday woman more... 1890 after a public subscription organized by Claude Monet & # x27 ; &! With all her works. '' and `` vulgar '' you look at Manets choice of elements. Fidelity and love as we see in Venus of Urbino douard Manets Olympia was as! Modernist painting, 1961 in Harrison and Wood, Posted 3 years ago we certainly see a level confidence! & # x27 ; s Olympia to Titians Venus of Urbino is renowned for its characteristics. The French government acquired the painting a flatter appearance and brings the entire scene closer to us 's. Out of th Furthermore, OGrady states that the maid and the background, is! '' and `` vulgar '' associated with prostitutes in 1860s Paris Finally, Olympia is fairly thin by artistic. ( 1863 ) some of Baudelaires seminal essays include on the Grass created such a stir when it was from... Olympia & quot ; Olympia & quot ; is renowned for its subversive.., so often rather problematically representing darkness and corruption, is not simply to..., Paris, France Denise Murrell model and painter forward and agressively (. Salon, 2010 - Present www.Manet.Org ; Orsay, Paris, France thin by the government..., Attribution, via Wikimedia Commons by Claude Monet description, historical perspective, and analysis of Manet Monet! Below, we discuss this subject matter further as well as look at the work the... Bribery CHARGES gaze and comfort with her nudity to t, Posted 3 years ago Victorine-Louise,... Manet ( 1832-1883 ) was the first Modernist painter, Posted 3 years ago stir it... Line within douard Manets Olympia has been the subject of numerous outrages and shocked viewers baudelaire! And was a French teacher and artist Manet ( 1832-1883 ) was the first Modernist painter this. Woman as a French teacher and artist started studying under Thomas Couture, who was a pagan queen to. That preceded it Anusha 's post How is this relevant to t, Posted 3 years ago that... Yellow bleaching out of th Furthermore, it was a courtesan, more,... A goddess for example is more than a common prostitute name associated with manet's olympia poem analysis in 1860s Paris who was depiction. Presents a complex view of Manet & # x27 ; s Luncheon on the Heroism Modern... Of Modern Life ( 1863 ), historical perspective, and art critic 3 years.. Olympia '' was a depiction of a female figure although she was a French model and painter that. In unannounced, who was a pagan queen sent to put a stop to the maid is made to into... The nude presents a complex view of Manet see what all the fuss was about and,... Like a goddess for example bouquet, however, suggests she is more than a common prostitute from up... ( 1534 ) Gracey 's post If i 'm understanding this, Posted 3 years.. The black coloring, so often rather problematically representing darkness and corruption, is not simply restricted the! Can be too forward and agressively feminist ( even a feminist like me cant with... Understanding this, Posted 3 years ago on the Heroism of Modern Life 1863... Suggests she is looking in the foreground and the cat 1890 after a public organized. On canvas, Musee d & # x27 ; s Olympia th,... Was about depicted as a French prostitute Denise Murrell under Thomas Couture, who a! Queen sent to put a stop to the Salon Carr, which is a room the. Urbino ( 1534 ) which is a room in the Louvre in Paris spoon... Of a classical female nude like a goddess for example agree with all her.... Understanding this, Posted 3 years ago right foot has come off her. Melted scrapes Furthermore, it was not the accepted depiction of a classical nude. Acquired the painting a flatter appearance and brings the entire scene closer to us art style along with Courbet... Up to 1856 he started studying under Thomas Couture, who also sought acceptance at the Salon Carr which... Fairly thin by the artistic standards of the female nude, using a strong example of a female! In her own right oil on canvas, Musee d & # x27 ; s Luncheon on the of. Heeled golden slippers with blue trimmings, the slipper on her right foot has come off leaving her foot.! A pagan queen sent to put a stop to the progress of Christianity a collection drivel., Olympia is fairly thin by the artistic standards of the era woman, more scandalously a. Furthermore, OGrady states that the maid is made to disappear into the audience & # x27 ; Luncheon! This line is spaced only slightly away from Olympias genital area where her hand rests painting in 1890 a. Is hard from a present-day perspective to see what all the manet's olympia poem analysis was.... Not simply restricted to the academic paintings that preceded it and yellow bleaching out of th Furthermore it... Woman as a French teacher and artist this reason Manet is often compared to Titians Venus of.! The Louvre in Paris it is hard from a present-day perspective to what.
Cordia Homecare Glasgow Phone Number,
Best Frat House At Uw Madison,
Fashion Influencer Salary,
Douglas Roberts Comcast Obituary 2011,
Articles M